Wellington Learning and Research Centre
Menu
  • About us
    • Partnerships
    • Contact us
  • Projects
    • Partnership with Harvard GSE Faculty
    • Measuring the unmeasured impacts of schools.
  • Professional Learning
  • Lesson Study
  • Digital Philosophy
  • Resources
    • The Research Process
    • Podcast
    • Videos
  • Blog
Browse: Home » Engagement: Just because they’re busy, doesn’t mean they’re learning anything.

Engagement: Just because they’re busy, doesn’t mean they’re learning anything.

Carl Hendrick 29th March 2015 Respond

By Carl Hendrick. 

I’ve long thought that one of the weakest proxy indicators of effective learning is engagement, and yet it’s a term persistently used by school leaders (and some researchers) as one of the most important measures of quality. In fact many of the things we’ve traditionally associated with effective teachers may not be indicative of students actually learning anything at all.

At the #ascl2015 conference last Friday, the always engaging Professor Rob Coe gave a talk entitled ‘From Evidence to Great Teaching’ and reiterated this claim. Take the following slide – How many ‘outstanding’ lessons have been awarded so based on this checklist?

Prof. Rob Coe From Evidence to Great Teaching ASCL 20 Mar 2015

Now these all seem like key elements of a successful classroom, so what’s the problem? and more specifically, why is engagement is such a poor proxy indicator – surely the busier they are, the more they are learning?

This paradox is explored by Graham Nuthall in his book ‘The Hidden Lives of Learners,’ (2007) in which he writes:

“Our research shows that students can be busiest and most involved with material they already know. In most of the classrooms we have studied, each student already knows about 40-50% of what the teacher is teaching.” p.24

Nuthall’s work shows that students are far more likely to get stuck into tasks they’re comfortable with and already know how to do as opposed to the more uncomfortable enterprise of grappling with uncertainty and indeterminate tasks. A good example of this as Alex Quigley has pointed out is that engagement in the form of the seemingly visible activity of highlighting is often “little more than colouring in.” Furthermore, teachers are more than happy to sanction that kind of stuff in the name of fulfilling that all important ‘engagement’ proxy indicator so prevalent in lesson observation forms.

The other difficulty is the now constant exhortation for students to be ‘motivated’ (often at the expense of subject knowledge and depth) but motivation in itself is not enough. Nuthall writes that:

“Learning requires motivation, but motivation does not necessarily lead to learning.”p.35

Motivation and engagement and vital elements in learning but it seems to be what they are used in conjunction with that determines impact. It is right to be motivating students but motivated to do what? If they are being motivated to do the types of tasks they already know how to do or focus on the mere performing of superficial tasks at the expense of the assimilation of complex knowledge then the whole enterprise may be a waste of time.

Learning is in many cases invisible as outlined many times by David Didau and is certainly not linear but rather more nebulous in actuality. As Prof. Coe reminds us, ‘learning happens when people have to think hard’ but unfortunately there is no easy way of measuring this, so what does he suggest is effective in terms of evidencing quality?

Ultimately he argues that it comes down to a more nuanced set of practitioner/student skills, habits and conditions that are very difficult to observe, never mind measure. Things like “selecting, integrating, orchestrating, adapting, monitoring, responding” and which are contingent on “context, history, personalities, relationships” and which all work together to create impact and initiate effective learning. So while engagement and motivation are important elements in learning they should be seen as part of a far more complex conglomerate of factors that traditional lesson observations have little hope of finding in a 20 min drive-by.

This is where a more robust climate of research and reflective practice can inform judgements. It’s true that more time for teachers to be critically reflective will improve judgements but we also need to be more explicit in precisely what it is we are looking for and accept that often the most apparent classroom element may also be the most misleading.

 

Slides: Prof. Rob Coe:  From Evidence to Great Teaching ASCL 20 Mar 2015

Nuthall, Graham (2007). The Hidden Lives of Learners. Wellington: New Zealand Council for Educational Research Press

Filed under: Blog and Tagged: Learning Communities, Professional Learning, Teaching & Learning
← Previous Next →

Latest Tweets

  • RT @DanielHugill: Thanks to @RufusWilliam, @AceThatTest, and @wellylearning for resources, blogs, and links used in a CPD session for colle…4 years ago
  • RT @robin_macp: We're going to spend a bit of time today discussing this table by @dylanwiliam about student responses to feedback, cited i…4 years ago
  • RT @EducationFest: Next year's Festival of Education will take place on the 20-21 June 2019. Tickets go on sale from 29 June 2018. You can…4 years ago
  • RT @tombennett71: Leaving lovely @WellingtonUK @EducationFest. Thanks to them, and to the amazing speakers who pitched in for the researchE…4 years ago
  • RT @ProfCoe: I have written a blog on what makes crap assessment (I’m not sure if that’s the exact title) to accompany my talk at #Educatio…4 years ago
  • RT @TLPMsF: @Claire_Hill_ and I will be speaking at #EducationFest tomorrow Period 3 in the Concert Room. Our session title is: What does a…4 years ago
Follow Us

Archives

August 2022
MonTueWedThuFriSatSun
« May  
1234567
891011121314
15161718192021
22232425262728
293031 

Sitemap

  • About us
    • Contact us
    • Partnerships
  • Blog
  • Digital Philosophy
    • Choose Your Own Device Scheme
  • Lesson Study
    • Biology Department: Reflections on a lesson study
  • Navigating research: A guide for teachers and school leaders
  • Professional Learning
    • Academic
    • Initial Teacher Training
    • Leadership
    • Pastoral
    • Specialist
    • Technology Professional Learning Strand
  • Projects
    • Closing the Gap
    • Mayor’s Excellence Fund Project
    • Mayor’s Excellence Fund Project
    • Measuring the unmeasured impacts of schools.
    • Partnership with Harvard GSE Faculty
  • Resources
    • Access to free research journals, reports and papers
    • Grit Resources
    • Growth Mindset Resources
    • Metacognition: An Overview
    • Podcast
    • Resources List for Research Topics on Growth Mindset/Grit Resilience/Meta Cognition
    • The Research Process
  • Sample Page
  • Videos
  • WCLR Journal
    • Issuu 1
    • Issuu 2

Tag Cloud

Assessment edtech education Educational reform Emotional intelligence Enrichment Examination Extension Feedback Google Growth Mindset Harkness Ideas Independent learning Learning Communities Lectures Lesson Observation Maths onenote Open Door Pedagogy Professional Learning Research SEN Super-curriculum Teaching & Learning WCPCI WellingTEN

  • May 2017
  • April 2017
  • February 2017
  • January 2017
  • December 2016
  • November 2016
  • October 2016
  • September 2016
  • February 2016
  • January 2016
  • November 2015
  • October 2015
  • September 2015
  • July 2015
  • June 2015
  • May 2015
  • April 2015
  • March 2015
  • January 2015
  • December 2014
  • November 2014
  • October 2014
  • September 2014
  • August 2014
  • June 2014
  • May 2014
  • March 2014
  • February 2014